Question about
ski3r247

Galaxy Nexus, Galaxy Note, or Lumia 800?

My iPhone 4 may be truly finished...
I am a cash strapped uni student on Telus in Canada, so that is where the list comes from. I am bored of iOS, and not excited about the 4S. Telus has three stand-out choices for me, two of which carry caveat. I have long said that I would not switch to Android, only Windows Phone, but the Galaxy Nexus has changed my mind. The Galaxy Nexus is available now, however the Note and 800 are listed as 'Coming Soon.' Time is an issue here, which likely puts the Nexus as my front-runner, but I am looking for input. Thanks!
top answers
community pick
timchoi89

If you want timely updates and the pure Google experience, go with the Galaxy Nexus.

If you like large phones that would be great for videos and web browsing, go for the Note. I went to HK for about 2.5 weeks recently and, if you didn't own an iPhone, you either had a GSII or a Note. I played with it and it seems to be a fantastic device.

If you're heavily entrenched in Microsoft's services or enjoy a slick very clean UI, then go for the 800.

In the end, it's all up to personal preferences. All three devices are great and will last you a while.
mark as good answer

9 people like this answer

Clicking the mark as good answer button helps us highlight the best answers.

sort by

7 more answers
falleninsea

With your time issue i would say go Nexus. its a good phone with decent hardware but what really makes it stand out is the OS. ICS is IMHO is the best version of the Android OS and is a huge improvement over Honeycomb.

If you can wait i would say go Note. its a large, phone provides more versatility i think than the Nexus. its easier to us as a mini tablet, has a better camera and for the most part better hardware than the GN. its also supposed to be getting ICS soon .

All of the Android devices have great integration to Googles offering of stuff and you know they will work well and not cost you more for the most part.

the Lumia is looking to be a nice device the OS is getting better and has a very different UI than the other and also has good integration to the Microsoft world. My concerns with the Win Phones is i don't know any one that has one. with the Android and iPhone its really easy to borrow a friends phone and see how it feels and functions. i can't do that on a Win Phone.
mark as good answer

3 people like this answer

agbenny

If you need a Android device, go for Nexus, if OS isn't matter then Lumia. If you need a multimedia device, and not a phone primarily then Note.
mark as good answer

1 person likes this answer

Fanfoot

Personal choice mostly. I'd say avoid the Note since its almost certainly too big. Have you tried one of the larged 4.3-inch plus phones in your hand? How does it feel? If it seems fine with you then the Nexus is your phone if you like Android. It has the stock Android experience, will get updates, and is the only phone out right now with ICS. Which you really want. Its better. If you 'think different' the Windows Phones really look nice, and Nokia makes some great hardware so the Lumia 800 is probably a fine choice. Usually it would have the better camera, though I hear its nothing special (neither is the 5Mpixel Nexus from what I hear). Also the 800 has no front facing camera so this would be a bad choice if you want to do video conferencing from your phone. Which I assume is probably not an issue for you.
mark as good answer

0 people like this answer

TheoC

I'd avoid the Lumia 800 purely because the 900 is about to be released in the US and one might assume Nokia will bring it elsewhere after that. The 800 is a good phone, but it's also a bit of a rush job.
mark as good answer

0 people like this answer

pika2000

If you only have money for 1 phone, go with the Galaxy Nexus. You won't regret it. Any previous annoyance with Android (lag) are pretty much gone on the GNexus. Don't bother with any other Android phones that are not ICS.
mark as good answer

0 people like this answer

kushkm

If you are a student, the Nokia 800 will fit your lifestyle the best since Windows Phone has the best social networking integration. I have a HTC WP7, and really enjoy it. The design of the Nokia is awesome. Android is free, its not worth spending your hard earned money for it on a contract carrier. Android is great for the prepaid phones since it is cheap.
mark as good answer

0 people like this answer

Sergei

I'd say definitely the Galaxy Note.

As a student needing to take notes all the time, the Note could be the only thing you need with you through your day, and that would be very cool indeed. It has the big screen, the pen, the battery life. It is big, but unlike a ring binder you can get it in a pocket.

The Nexus I feel is a little disappointing in hardware terms. Good, but not extra-special. And frankly, I think the lack of an SD card slot is madness. Its big selling point is Ice Cream Sandwich, but that's promised for the Note as well, possibly as soon as March. You'll get Android upgrades first on a Nexus of course, but if you're technically inclined at all you can root an Android phone and take care of that yourself.

I think the Lumia 800 (or 900) is a lovely piece of hardware and very tempting. I currently have an N900 and would have been looking at a Nokia Windows phone as a replacement for that when it finally got too old, maybe a year or two, especially if they still looked as good. But then Samsung introduced the Note, and I'm going to get one as soon as it reaches the market here. A phone big enough to takes notes and sketch on is just irresistible as far as i"m concerned.
mark as good answer

0 people like this answer

share:

Related questions

8 users following this question:

This question has been viewed 1747 times.
Last activity .

Tips for giving the best answers

Sometimes it's just little details that separates a great and not so great answer! Here are a few simple tips to keep in mind:

1
Be complete and thorough. Don't skimp on the details!
2
Try not to answer with a question. Because that's not really an answer, right?
3
A little research goes a long way. Back up your claims and assumptions!
4
Try to be patient, tech questions can be complicated.
5
You are awesome for both reading this and answering questions.