Question about
kts2005

Am I missing the purpose of tablets?

I was able to pick up one of the $149 32GB HP Touchpads this past weekend and it was delivered yesterday. I was excited to get home and test it out, but I only ended up messing around with it for about 10 minutes after setup. I was sitting there trying to browse the web and scroll through screens, but I found myself wanting my 13" VAIO and wireless mouse instead. I am I just not a tablet person, or could this be attributed to hardware/WebOS? I wasn't thrilled with the mail app and testing out www.twitter.com was nothing like using Twitter on a PC. I've briefly played around with a friend's Tab 10.1 and seemed to love it, but I'm not sure I'd prefer that over a small laptop either. Maybe I just need to save up for a Macbook Air-esque device. What do you think?
top answers
kts2005's pick
cass

I think a tablet is the ultimate bed device. Pretty much every night I'm using my iPad to watch a video or check twitter/facebook before I go to sleep. It's much easier to do that kind of stuff with a tablet than a laptop.

When I need to do work, I'll always grab the laptop, but for moments where I'm in bed, want to sit in my kitchen, or watch something with a friend, I think the portability/size of a tablet can't be beat.
mark as good answer

3 people like this answer

Clicking the mark as good answer button helps us highlight the best answers.

kts2005's pick
keppy

I think it depends on what you do on the internet. Personally I read a ton of articles and browse a lot of news sites, and to me that experience is vastly superior on a tablet than it is on a laptop. Especially lounging around on the couch. I hate fighting with the position of a laptop while on the couch, fighting with scrolling, etc. I think the reading experience on a tablet is lot more comfortable.

If you don't do a lot of reading on the net, then you may not think a tablet provides any convenience for you.
mark as good answer

3 people like this answer

kts2005's pick
nitehawk

I love using my iPhone on the couch so I think if you have a smartphone that you love, then you don't NEED a tablet. However, I understand how people would love the bigger screen and more power. Also the fact that using it doesn't take up your phone battery and you can have your iPhone docked to a stereo so you can listen to music and still use your tablet. I think in the next 2 years there will be a race to the bottom with tablets because I really see them being valuable in the kitchen and carried around frequently. They won't become GPS or alarm clocks or even event planners the way smartphones have, but they will be portable information viewers.

Right now tablets are a novelty the way that the iPod was a novelty. They are more necessary for people who aren't in love with their smartphones in my opinion. Also when you spend $500 on something, you aren't likely you use it as much while cooking/preparing in the kitchen like I see people using them when they are cheaper. If I bought an iPad2 today for $500 I would never take it to a place like Starbucks, the library, subway, a friend's house or any place where I could get water damage or crack the screen when someone bumped into my bag. If it were as cheap as a Kindle I wouldn't be as hesitant to bring it outside of my house. I realize there are cases and covers, but spending over $500 on something so easily stolen, dropped or cracked that's not really necessary to begin with makes me nervous and I think lots of mainstream people think the same way.

A laptop is a little less fragile but certainly more necessary. When you bring your laptop somewhere it's different because it's not viewed as a toy. I am not someone to bring my laptop on the subway just because, but I would like to have a tablet on the subway as a bigger version of my smartphone.

Right now tablets are a novelty and at best a bigger version of our smartphones. Hopefully they become more powerful so they can be used similar to the Motorola Atrix in that you have something you carry around that fits in your pocket, you can dock it and make it be more powerful with a bigger screen.

I would like to take it a step further like Sony does with the Vaio Z and have a phone that docks to a portable tablet for carrying around for leisure/class/subway/car, but then at home it docks to a full keyboard and full size screen and gets added horsepower. Obviously the big downfall with that is that when your phone breaks your SOL, but with flash memory hopefully it won't be that way. I really see people being able to walk around with something the size of our wallet in our pants (maybe it replaces our wallet), then having a larger case to dock it in to view on a bigger screen that would also add battery life, extra buttons, more power etc that would fit in a small backpack or even a large coat. Then being able to put that small wallet sized phone into a docking station at our work/home to sync everything and get added power plus the benefit of full size peripherals.
mark as good answer

1 person likes this answer

sort by

4 more answers
dstrick64

It's the old "Use the proper tool for the job" dogma. After years with laptops and smartphones I now have had a tablet for a week and I see already how it fits in. I had a fairly lightweight laptop (ThinkPad widescreen) that was top notch, fast and easy to use; excellent keyboard and touchpad, etc. I used it for work and also for mobile computing. Light enough to sit on your lap and did not run hot. However it was unwieldy for use on the couch, recliner, porch swing etc. mainly because it was awkward getting to the keys and most of the time trying to hold it with one hand while typing and mousing with the other got tiresome really quickly.
Next enter the smartphone: super light, super portable, long battery life (days), and one hand operation for most things. I used it for a couple of years for those quick "refer to the Web" questions and all of the handy apps that turned it into a Swiss Army chainsaw. The only drawback (and it was not really a serious one) was the minimal screen space. That was mostly just a minor annoyance from time to time because the Web and apps quickly optimized everything to the device.
But, once I got the TouchPad I found that it is the ideal middle ground, providing lightweight ease of use, no awkward "how do I maneuver this screen and keyboard without messing something up" when I needed to get up and do something else, and it provides the apps and quick navigating of a smartphone. Plus it is great for reading books, pdf's, etc.
Switching apps is very neat and slick with the WebOS cards and the new Advanced Browser has tabs, so I now have a replacement for my pricey laptop, because when I need a physical keyboard I pair up my bluetooth keyboard and voila! wireless connection is much more flexible than a screen and keyboard hinged together in a configuration that makes the possibility of a broken laptop a frightening possibility.
Thanks.
mark as good answer

1 person likes this answer

kts2005

Thanks guys. I think the fact that I have the iPhone 4 has something to do with the fact that I feel I don't need a tablet...I'm a big fan of minimizing noise and clutter, and I don't think a tablet eliminates any of my other devices at this point. I'm guessing the iPad would be a step in that direction, but it still doesn't have things like SMS/MMS, and I refuse to pay for another wireless data plan for a non-cell phone device. I think I'm clinging to my laptop because I like the speed & multitasking ability--I usually have multiple Chrome tabs open and switching between things is so much easier/faster than with a tablet.

I agree with you Peter, I think having phones dock into & power tablets/laptops is where we should focus. I liked the idea of the Motorola Atrix & laptop dock, but I think Motorola priced themselves out of mainstream adoption.
mark as good answer

0 people like this answer

roberto

I'm primarily using it as a consumption device. Videos, reading, and the occasional game. Beyond that I have found little use for it.
mark as good answer

0 people like this answer

UncleMuscles

If you are only going to have one device then it has to be a laptop because it is good at so many different things. However, sometimes it is nice to have a device that is great at doing a few things-- even if it is not so great at some other things.

For me, the iPad is the best electronic device that I have for reading: books, Instapaper, internet, comics, RSS, etc. I am a voracious reader and I find reading more pleasant in the tablet form factor.
mark as good answer

0 people like this answer

share:

Related questions

7 users following this question:

This question has been viewed 483 times.
Last activity .

Tips for giving the best answers

Sometimes it's just little details that separates a great and not so great answer! Here are a few simple tips to keep in mind:

1
Be complete and thorough. Don't skimp on the details!
2
Try not to answer with a question. Because that's not really an answer, right?
3
A little research goes a long way. Back up your claims and assumptions!
4
Try to be patient, tech questions can be complicated.
5
You are awesome for both reading this and answering questions.