SouthPaw

MicroUSB cell phone chargers are not an answer.

So the UN is now recommencing that international trade organization require MicroUSB chargers stanard for cell phones
.
They made this move so that chargers are not thrown away with the upgrade to a new phone. They want to dramatically reduce the ewaste. Great idea and would make gadget life easier.

And now the BUT!!! The MicroUSB chargers are not interchangeable. I have DC and AC and chargers for my Motorola Adventure and another DC and AC charger for a Blackberry Pearl Flip. But they are not interchangeable. The blackberry adventure say not authorized charger. I can't use a MicroUSB cable with a AC USB or DC to USB power adapter. I can't use a MicroUSB cable with a Computer unless it runs windows XP and I load a special driver. (On work PC the driver install is disallowed by profile).

I don't understand the reasons for the lock out.

With the manufacturers locking out non original equipment chargers how will the standard help?
8 replies
gb3

Did we they miss a part of the standardization specifications? Just be cause the connector is Micro USB doesn't mean the voltage (and current) input would be the same. What is the point of a standard connector if you can't mix and match the charger?
0 like dislike
SouthPaw

Acually the MicroUSB Connector must meet certain voltage and amperage guidelines to get UL listing. All US carriers require UL listings of their phones.The problem is the phone manufaturers place chips in the power adpters on the data lines so that the phone will only work with their over priced adapters for a single model.
0 like dislike
tabbott

Standardization of mobile phone chargers is the right move in the grand scheme of things. I personally have thrown out far too many obsolete and useless phone chargers in my years of usage. I am looking forward to the day I can be at a friends house, notice I need to charge my phone, and be able to use his charger without issue. The Green movement is big right now and this is just one small piece in the puzzle to help our society correct it's wasteful habits.
0 like dislike
dave

Yeah, providing the standards are implemented correctly and with proper enforcement, I think this is a fantastic idea. However, it sounds like this plan in Europe doesn't really have any teeth to it.
0 like dislike
Dpmt

But its not only the EU its the CTIA too, and they have teeth.
0 like dislike
SouthPaw

But the companies specificly engineered into the adapaters a lockout for the planned saving. How scumbaggy is that. So Company says we will use MiroUSB as a standard but you still need to pay $39.99 to motorola for $5 a power adapter.
0 like dislike
brett

I thought that along with the charger standardization they were also requiring the phone manufacturers to use compatible female ports on the phones.

Also, you can't expect any data to necessarily be transferred and I WOULD expect incompatibility there. For charging though, I think they want all of the devices to be able to be charged by the new standard.

Part of the problem is in the adapters like you cant use some old iPod AC adapters to charge the iPhone and the iPod Touch. But I think now that the resolution is passed, most new adapters should work with any phone.

Also, why do you have a DC charger? For car use? They weren't trying to also cut out car chargers, just keep down the amount of overall chargers tossed out. I know that when I was in France for a year I used many different MicroUSB chargers for my phone from different brands and carriers and countries and everything worked fine. This was before that resolution was passed as well.
0 like dislike
Dpmt

Because the EU is getting involved and Europeans buy a lot of cellphones. So you act quickly as an industry to prevent the government from hitting you with some law by "self regulating".
0 like dislike