ryan

Ask us anything (about gdgt)

I think if there's one thing that constantly impresses me about this site -- and when I say site, I mean the incredibly active and intelligent users that comprise its community -- it's been the quality of the conversations, content, and knowledge that's already been gathered here since we launched last July.

The team has been pretty hunkered down over the last couple months banging out new features and thinking about the future of gdgt, and I know Peter and I have been spending even more time than ever behind the scenes guiding that product development. So he and I wanted to take a step back for a bit and listen to what you're thinking about gdgt.

We want to hear how we're doing: what you want from the site, what's working and might work better, even (and especially) what we're sucking at. Feel free to ask us anything about gdgt -- big or small, what we're doing, what we're thinking, whatever. I can't guarantee we'll have a worthwhile answer or reply everything, but we'll sure as hell try. Don't hold back, we're listening!

sort by

155 replies
ryan

Man, not a day goes by that I don't regret that stupid freaking Flash widget. I'll be retiring sooner than later, but we can look into a fix.

Can you tell me a little more about what you're seeing? Browser, OS, plugins, anything else that might vary between your two browsers.
0 like dislike
teapower

How about the podcast player, it's not a big deal for me because I don't listen to the podcast on the site but I think it would be nice if you guys could change that into something non-flash.
0 like dislike
ryan

I wouldn't mind doing that in theory, and HTML5 will make that possible, but it'll probably be a little while (due to the finalization of the spec, browser support, finding a good player, etc.). If it helps put things in context, I think well over 90% of all our listens come out of iTunes, so it's not the highest priority. At least not like the Flash widget, anyway.
0 like dislike
toddjy

I also see only a black box. I'm using Firefox 3.5.8 on XP. The only add-on I have is NoScript; I have it set to allow globally, but DoubleClick somehow got blocked.
0 like dislike
drpatter

Sure, I replied back by email that one time you were emailing people that were seeing the problem, too. Using Windows XP pro, FF v3.5.8, with plugins: Adblock pro (which i have disabled for gdgt and subdomains) and Firebug.

Like I said, I don't have any crazy stuff going on. I just can't see the gdgt widget....which breaks the site for me. Can't use it....in FF.
0 like dislike
peter

It may be that Adblock is still blocking the widget even though you've whitelisted the site and subdomains. We are going to be moving away from a flash-based widget for users' gadget lists, so regardless this issue will be going away.
0 like dislike
shadez

I too think it's the AdBlock Plus that's blocking the Widget since I've tried using it with and without AdBlock
0 like dislike
ryan

You might also want to check into whether you're blocking Flash. Doesn't sound like you are, but that will obviously cause issues.
0 like dislike
drpatter

It even happens when I disable ABP all together.
0 like dislike
groven1023

will the Austin event be free admission?
0 like dislike
peter

The Austin event is free admission, all-ages, and open to everyone. Please feel free to bring as many friends as you want!
0 like dislike
D1TTON

Fantastic job on the site/podcast! Keep up the great work.

@Ryan/Peter Could you do an event in Toronto? So many Canadian fans!
0 like dislike
peter

We don't have any plans to do an event in Canada right now, but we would like to do some international events next year.
0 like dislike
D1TTON

Sounds great! Keep Toronto on your radar, we'd love to have you guys!
0 like dislike
groven1023

that is amazing!

thank you for having this event, I really though I would miss out on GDGT happenings due to the fact that I live in Texas

My wife and I will both be there!
0 like dislike
peter

Awesome! Please find me and say hi!
0 like dislike
groven1023

Dude, done

You just made my day!
0 like dislike
coologuy1957

will we have to wear name tags with our username??? lol
0 like dislike
groven1023

Name tags might be fun!
0 like dislike
ryan

We did name tags the first two events, actually! We had them custom printed, they said "hi, my gdgt name is...."

So dorky.
1 like dislike
coologuy1957

sweet!! that will definitely cut down that awkward intro from EVERYONE..... :)
0 like dislike
groven1023

Is it possible to search for friends without using facebook or twitter.

just searching the database of users on the site

I'm not sure if it's possible but I haven't found a way to do it

that would be a really cool feature
0 like dislike
ryan

Hmm, not yet. Like, just search by name?
0 like dislike
groven1023

exactly, search by user name
0 like dislike
Dpmt

Search by real name would be nice too. Would have saved me the 15 minutes I spent looking for Joshua Topolsky and the two hours I spent hunting down Brad Linder.
0 like dislike
ryan

Not to be a smartass, but: www.google.com­/search­?q­=site:gdgt.com­+brad­+linder (alternately, www.google.com­/search­?q­=gdgt­+brad­+linder). Same works for Josh, or anyone for that matter. But yeah, we need search by name.
0 like dislike
Dpmt

What do you think I ended up doing?
0 like dislike
JoseROrtiz

Not really a question; more of a suggestion: I love the fact that we are able to discuss a company as a whole instead of just focusing on a specific product. It would be cool if you could incorporate company performance and stats. Maybe leverage the Wolfram|Alpha API? Not sure how feasable that would be, but I think have that data there would serve as a great reference for discussions.
0 like dislike
peter

I think this is a great suggestion, it'd make sense to make some of that stuff more dynamic. I'll see what we can do!
0 like dislike
JustinCarone

One big issue I have is more with the rest of the internet than with gdgt. Every time I am reading an article somewhere or looking for products online I always want to know what the gdgt community thinks of it. Unfortunately the commenters and reviewers on most sites are lacking when it comes to the insightfulness and maturity found on gdgt. Is it possible to allow comments on news articles from outside gdgt so that more interesting conversations could occur on the site without crossing legal boundaries of the sites publishing the articles?
0 like dislike
peter

Yes, discussions/comments are coming to News very soon!
0 like dislike
teapower

This is one feature I can't wait for.
0 like dislike
ryan

Yeah, this is actually one of the many reasons we completely rebuilt our discussions system. I'm not sure yet if news discussions will launch at the same time, but if not, it'll be following very soon thereafter.
0 like dislike
JustinCarone

That is great news! I cannot wait for this feature to roll out now. No longer will I have to scan through page after page of mind numbing comments on other sites, there will be actual substantive, intelligent conversations here instead.
0 like dislike
ChrisB

This is a small thing, but I'm curious...
When I click "Add New" why is "News" the default section rather than "Gadget"?
0 like dislike
ryan

When we launched news a few weeks ago, we changed the default to make sure people who wanted to add stuff to the site were aware it was there and might feel compelled to start plugging news into the site. It'd probably be better if it just remembered your last setting though. What do you think?
0 like dislike
ChrisB

I think it should always default to "Gadget". For a new user, having "News" be the 1st thing they see could give off the wrong impression. I think the addition of news is great, but you want them to help build the ultimate gadget database right?

I would suggest this:
img413.imageshack.us­/img413­/1386­/gdgtmokcup.png
Its a terrible mock up, but you get the idea. I'd use the type of "widget" you have on the front page for breaking news or featured products. It would highlight the new sections so users know its there, but I think most people will be looking to add a gadget when they click the "add new" button.
0 like dislike
Dpmt

I agree it should default to Gadget.
0 like dislike
ryan

Sounds like we need to make that change! I'll have the team make it happen.
0 like dislike
ryan

Update here: we pushed some new code today which defaults to gadgets when you hit the add page, as well as remembers which add type you last selected when you browse back.
0 like dislike
beau

Has a decision been made as to whether you say "g-d-g-t" or "gadget" when referring to the site? In the last podcast Ryan called it "gadget" (referring to the gdgt Austin party) but Peter said "g-d-g-t" (referring to the gdgt podcast).
0 like dislike
ryan

Heh, I don't think there's really a "decision" on this per se. To quote our about page (which has stayed the same since day one): "gdgt (like 'gadget' -- or g-d-g-t)"

We started saying the letters early on because we wanted people to be totally clear that you should go to gdgt.com -- not gadget.com (or even engadget.com). I feel like people have started to hear of us or have maybe even been to the site at this point, so I stopped using g-d-g-t since it's a bit clumsier to say.

I'll take the blame (or credit) on this one, though, since Peter has been consistent in saying the letters!
0 like dislike
peter

I prefer "g-d-g-t" because it's a little more distinctive than just saying "gadget", plus, as Ryan notes, it lets people know how to spell the URL.
0 like dislike
ryan

I'm just glad we didn't go with the codename, which was "devixe" (said like "device").
0 like dislike
Murphy1d

In my head I've been calling it "Gidget" just cuz it sounds fun.
1 like dislike
ryan

Yeah, don't do that.
-1 like dislike
teapower

That's the best codename you guys could come up with? I was hoping for something a little better/extremely weird and off topic.
0 like dislike
ryan

Oh, there were literally dozens and dozens. It wasn't the best we came up with, but it was the only one we could get the .com for (so we could put up an alpha version of the site) without needing to buy it from someone.
0 like dislike
teapower

We could we hear some of the others?
0 like dislike
ryan

There were a lot, but another decent one I came up with was dvice, which I almost picked up (but just couldn't get into). As it turns out, a few months later NBC / Sci-Fi channel grabbed it and used it for their DVICE gadget blog.

I also own apparat.us, which I love, but it's a little too geeky for a consumer site. In the end, it was just super hard to beat a four letter domain that spelled the single, definitive word we were trying to get behind: gadget(s).
1 like dislike