Discussion about
awe210

Why must this product stink so much? Why not include a DVR and apps?

if it did, it could take out Tivo and Roku

sort by

8 replies
dave

What stinks about it? It has the best Netflix integration on the market, a great YouTube app (which even Roku lacks), and even flickr support.

Yeah, apps would be nice, but I don't think this sucks by any means!
3 like dislike
UncleMuscles

Since it has 8GB of onboard storage it seems likely that apps are coming (probably in the next 6 months). DVR is never going to happen though. Can anyone imagine Steve Jobs and the cable industry working together?
1 like dislike
j2w218

The DVR won't happen because Apple wants to make money from shows via iTunes.
0 like dislike
AckbarsFist

A DVR with 8 Gb of storage would suck...

I do agree though that it isn't a mature product. Apple have all the time and money in the world to make this anything they want it to be, but yet it's still a bit of a lame duck. Very held back IMHO.
1 like dislike
j2w218

There are apps available now, if you want to hack it. Check out: firecore.com­/atvflash
0 like dislike
dave

I think this is more indicative of the entire digital media player genre and how we watch TV actually. No one has been able to get it right yet and it's hard. The Boxee Box, Google TV, Roku, and Apple TV, while nice, still feel like a sort of hack in terms of the home theater.

All these devices just don't mesh well with the current experience, IMHO and feel like some sort of inelegant hack. Companies have been trying to bridge this gap between internet and television since WebTV.

It's a tough issue to solve, and until content providers are wholly onboard, I don't think there's going to be a truly awesome solution anytime soon!
0 like dislike
j2w218

Dude, if you think this sucks, then you are clueless and impatient. Does the iPhone suck in your mind? The iPad? Give it some time and realize what this products initial purpose is. To rent content from Apple. Be happy that they added Netflix, and one of the best UIs for Netflix. Roku is cheap tech. Tivo, which was the leader, needs to figure out their software.
0 like dislike
JasonTsay

It doesn't stink man. It's just very simple and does what it's meant to do very well without the extra crap on the side.
0 like dislike