Discussion about
zakkforchilli

Why do you think Apple has NOT added the ability to change your "theme" of iOS yet?

I'm about to write you all a book. Read it and love it, OR! just read the title, and answer.
Post brought to you by zfwp (zakkforchilli.wordpress.com)

iOS
As of right now, to change your "theme" or Graphical User Interface (GUI)—you have to jailbreak your iOS device and download another third-party application. Almost every phone / Mobile OS I've ever used and almost every phone / Mobile OS I've ever heard of, seen, studied—has had the ability to change the look and feel of your general, overall experience—right from the settings menu, right out of the box.

Apple, is a "right out of the box" type of company, yet there are tons of things Apple has yet to implement. We all know that Apple loves to take It's sweet sweet time when implementing features, so they can make sure there's always going to be something to throw in the next version / release.

But, isn't it quite inconvenient for them knowing that they're lacking a "crucial for some" feature, that has been around since I bought my first little crappy Virgin Mobile cell phone back like 12 years ago..? Almost every device wether it be Mobile, or Desktop, has the ability to skin or "theme."

OS X
The ability was there (STILL by a third-party software developer) to skin their older Operating System "10.4 Mac OS X Tiger"—yet removed in the next release. No-one has made another attempt to update that application for newer Mac OS X versions either. It's a shame. The app was called "Shapeshifter" by Panic Software. No-one has even taken another crack at it I don't believe.

Right now on OS X, all I can do is:
  • Change my highlights to different basic colors
  • Switch between Graphite and Aqua schemes for only like two different tiny sections of my entire interface..
  • Desktop photo... (haha)
  • Change icons (but automatically only with "CandyBar")
It's poop!

Windows
Windows has always had the ability to skin. Since WIndows 1 or whatever it was, you've been able to select from a (even though most were crappy) huge range of different skins. Starting in Windows 7 they brought Aero, which in It's own right is amazing on It's own, and there's no real reason to want to skin the crap out of it like you did prior with "Windowblinds." Around the time of WIndows 7, they even started hosting their own theme site. Simple, but hell, they were themes! Even Google Chrome and all of the other browsers have themes now.

You could customize every aspect of the Graphical User Interface from the Start Button to small accents all around the UI. All the cool kids that were either hackers or gamers, always had a sick theme going on all over the place. Icons, and all.

If someone finds an app that has been hiding from me, that allows you to skin Mac OS X, please let me know.

My final thought on this.. Is that Apple has a lot of pride. They simply don't believe they need to do allow people to change it much. They don't want people with crappy themes to disgrace them quite yet. Think about it. They've been taking huge INFLUENCES from Jailbreakers.. half of the past 2 MAJOR RELEASES of iOS have been features that Jailbreakers already implemented, and that people already dreamed up and asked for. Not just visual either, real functionality. Sure, most of the awesome ones seemed obvious and crucial, but come on.

Eventually they will cave. They can't go forever without allowing some "Desktop Customization."

sort by

11 replies
abczyx

Because they want an instantly recognisable brand. You know if you see a screenshot of iOS or OSX exactly what it is instantly, and that it's not say Android or Win 7.

I don't think Apple will add it. I don't think they want to, and to be honest given that almost every Windows user I know runs the default look (save very basic stuff like backgrounds, accessibility etc.), I don't think they need to.
2 like dislike
kherge

I agree with you on the point that Apple wants an instantly recognizable product. However, that alone is not a good excuse not to allow skinning. I've seen a lot of Android interfaces skinned, but I still know they are Android. The same can be said for any interface anybody frequents.

The only time this actually becomes a problem is when people go beyond skinning and actually make changes to the functionality of the interface. This is done by several manufacturers that sell Android devices.

I think a lot of people will be happy choosing their own color scheme. It will give them a greater sense of ownership.
0 like dislike
zakkforchilli

I know what you mean. A lot of advanced themes when you jailbreak your phone are to emulate others. I use to use a Palm Pre theme. It was my favorite. You could STILL ALWAYS tell it was an iPhone though. It couldn't change EVERYTHING..

But some themes did go far enough to cover it up. And no, it's NOT the reason they're not doing it. It can't be, it's ( i agree) not a good enough excuse. BUT surely possible.
1 like dislike
abczyx

But isn't that only because of the limitations of your skin? If you could have changed everything, you probably wouldn't be able to tell what it was.
0 like dislike
zakkforchilli

Yes that's true.. But some skins like to be minimal, if you really really want to change everything, you gotta be pretty good at it for one, and you gotta commit to spending all that time. But yes it's possible to completely change it.
0 like dislike
abczyx

I think it is good enough, though. The fact is, for most people re-skinning is either something they don't do or something that they don't feel particularly strongly about. The good things that Apple gets by keeping control (branding) far outweighs the downsides of irritating a small minority of users.

I personally identify Android handsets not because they instantly look like Android, but because I can quickly tell they're not iOS/WinPhone/Palm.
0 like dislike
zakkforchilli

Yeah in Windows 7, 8 at this point of course. Like i said, now, there's not reason for theming. You can't say that for Windows 2000, ME, any with the classic interface. XP looked good as well, but many people still skinned the shit out of it because you could still switch back to classic.

Can you still go Classic mode in 7 and 8?
0 like dislike
abczyx

Windows 7 has Classic mode, not sure about 8.
0 like dislike
zakkforchilli

I'll find out soon. I have the Beta.. Just haven't been using it much.
0 like dislike
lirand

Apple has never been big on customization. Mac OS X is still not very "customization friendly" and it has celebrated it's 10th anniversary lately. Don't hold your breath for themes on iOS (there are many other features that I believe Apple will prefer to address first)
0 like dislike
cdpinker

So many reasons - simplicity, consistency, brand recognition, priorities. I've yet to meet anyone who considers this a "crucial" feature! At the end of the day, who really cares about skinning these days? I'd much rather Apple concentrated on advancing the platform and developing features and functionality rather than cosmetics.

I don't think themes and skins have a big enough positive impact on any of Apple's product goals (i.e. deliver the best possible device that people love to use).
0 like dislike